Butler-Tarkington
Rent $1,200-$2,000/moButler-Tarkington, Indianapolis, IN 46208
SafetyA-
PrivacyMedium
Drive4m
Tree-lined residential pocket wrapped right around Butler's campus with classic homes and small apartment buildings.
Historic Hinkle Fieldhouse is your daily practice base, with football and soccer at the adjacent Bud and Jackie Sellick Bowl just steps away on the same Butler campus block. Everything in this guide is built around quick trips back to 510 W 49th St in Marion County.
Tree-lined residential pocket wrapped right around Butler's campus with classic homes and small apartment buildings.
The stretch between campus and Broad Ripple along College Avenue, full of newer apartments, coffee shops and easy Monon Trail access.
Indy's signature walkable village of restaurants, music venues and nightlife clustered along Broad Ripple Avenue and the Monon Trail.
Quiet, established neighborhood of historic homes and leafy streets just east of Meridian Street.
Downtown's polished arts-and-dining corridor with high-end apartment towers, restaurants and the Bottleworks District.
The neighborhoods above sit inside a twenty-minute drive of Hinkle Fieldhouse. But many athletes prioritize lifestyle, privacy, and prestige over commute — these are the areas across Indianapolis where athletes most often buy and rent, even though they’re a longer drive from the facility.
The metro's wealthiest suburb, blending a walkable brick-street historic village with sprawling custom estates on wooded acreage. Holliday Farms anchors the new-luxury segment with a Pete Dye golf course and gated Estates section holding the priciest, most private lots in the area.
Indianapolis's marquee luxury suburb, pairing a polished Arts & Design District with gated enclaves like Bridgewater Club and Springwood. Custom estates in its exclusive subdivisions command the metro's highest suburban prices.
The metro's premier waterfront, ringing the Geist Reservoir with multi-million-dollar estates featuring private docks, infinity pools, and the best water views in the state. Gated communities like Breakwater (just 35 custom homes, recent sales $2M–$3.5M) sit at the top of the market.
The old-money in-town corridor along North Meridian Street, lined with grand historic mansions on mature, tree-canopied lots in Meridian Hills, Crows Nest, and Williams Creek. Established prestige rather than new construction.